Why Dr. Andy Galpin Changed his Mind on Muscle Building Strategies, Fat Loss, and Fasting
22 Jun 2024 (3 months ago)
Intro
- Dr. Andy Galpin discusses the importance of being able to go 24 hours without food without experiencing negative cognitive, emotional, or physiological effects.
- He emphasizes the need for resilience in this aspect.
30% Off Your First Order AND a Free Gift Worth up to $60
- Dr. Andy Galpin promotes Thrive Market, a sponsor of his channel, offering a 30% discount and a free $60 gift for new customers.
- Thrive Market sells various products, including Baine supplements, freeze-dried beets, beet snacks, sustainable meat and seafood options, wheat bran, and other groceries.
- Customers can enjoy the convenience of shopping for all their groceries, including Bain-rich items, at a discounted price and have them delivered to their doorstep.
Primary Mechanisms for Muscle Growth
- Dr. Andy Galpin believes mechanical tension is the primary driver of muscle growth, with metabolic disturbances playing a lesser role.
- Muscle damage is a minimal contributor to muscle growth.
- The exact relationship between pain perception and muscle growth is still unclear.
- Muscle growth involves cellular sensitization, cell signaling cascade, and gene expression, not solely dependent on metabolic waste.
- Mechanical load and muscle damage are not always directly correlated, and muscle growth can occur without significant muscle damage.
- Isometric training can be beneficial for tissue activation, growth, and strength improvements, especially for rehabilitation or beginners.
- Isometric training can stimulate muscle growth, maintain muscle mass, and is convenient for hotel workouts.
- Holding a split squat position for 90 seconds can challenge muscles, burn calories, and lower glucose levels, but it's not a substitute for traditional barbell exercises.
- Isometric exercises can be a useful short-term tool for building muscle mass.
Building vs Maintaining Muscle
- The volume needed to maintain muscle mass depends on how long you've had it.
- Individuals who have maintained muscle mass for over a year may require less volume (around 10 working sets per muscle group per week), while those who recently gained muscle (within the last 12 months) may need more volume (closer to 15-20 working sets per muscle group per week).
- Muscle growth is limited by the number of nuclei in muscle fibers, but recent research suggests that muscle nuclei may be able to replicate, challenging traditional views of muscle growth.
- Plateaus in muscle growth can occur due to various factors, including the myonuclear domain, but they don't necessarily mean reaching one's genetic potential.
- Muscle growth can slow down over time due to factors like anabolic resistance and desensitization of signaling pathways.
- To overcome plateaus, individuals may need to increase training volume, protein intake, or focus on protein timing and quality.
- Plateaus are more likely to occur after five to eight years of training.
- Insufficient sleep, micronutrient deficiencies, or other lifestyle factors can also hinder muscle growth.
Protein Timing
- Total protein intake throughout the day is more relevant to muscle growth than the timing of meals.
- Even with intermittent fasting, muscle growth is not compromised for most people unless there are practical problems.
- Protein timing matters for athletes and those trying to maximize muscle growth, but for most people, it doesn't matter much.
- The body is not very particular about protein timing unless someone is trying to maximize muscle growth or has a very high muscle mass.
- Practical issues, such as difficulty in consuming large amounts of protein in a short time frame, can make protein timing more important for certain individuals.
Compressed Eating Window & Fasting
- Dr. Andy Galpin found that neglecting calorie intake was detrimental to performance, even with sufficient protein intake.
- Low caloric intake can cause sleep disturbances and hormonal imbalances, such as increased sex hormone binding globulin (SHBG) and decreased testosterone.
- Consuming a higher carbohydrate intake can correct these issues and improve overall performance and recovery.
- A study on female bodybuilders showed a significant drop in resting energy expenditure and testosterone after 24 weeks of 50% caloric restriction, with effects lasting for at least four months.
- To mitigate the negative effects of fasting, leaner and more active individuals should consume a higher carbohydrate intake on fasting days.
- Nutritional ketosis may not be beneficial for leaner and more active individuals.
Keto Diet
- Dr. Andy Galpin now believes that nutritional ketosis has more beneficial applications than previously thought and can be beneficial for the general population, especially those who don't exercise.
- However, he does not recommend a ketogenic diet for high performers, such as athletes or high-performing executives, as there is no clear benefit for performance.
- Dr. Galpin views nutritional ketosis as a way of covering up underlying dysfunctions in the body's physiology or biochemistry and recommends focusing on fixing the root cause of problems rather than just treating the symptoms.
- When making dietary changes, it's important to consider the balance between resilience and sensitivity to different foods and nutrients, as the body may become less resilient to certain foods or nutrients when they are removed and then reintroduced.
Optimizing vs Maximizing
- Prioritizing short-term optimization can hinder long-term adaptation, and vice versa.
- Extreme optimization can make individuals highly sensitive to small changes, while constant adaptation can lead to resilience but reduced performance.
- People who prioritize short-term gratification often face physical and mental health issues due to impulsive decisions and neglecting long-term well-being.
- Individuals who solely focus on long-term gratification may experience mental health problems due to constant worry and lack of presence in the moment.
- Finding a balance between short-term and long-term gratification is crucial to avoid potential mental health issues and enjoy life experiences.
- Optimizing for the present while making conscious efforts to ensure long-term well-being is a better approach than following all longevity expert advice.
Where to Find More of Dr. Galpin's Content
- Twitter and Instagram are the easiest places to find Dr. Galpin's content.
- His YouTube channel is not particularly active, but it's a good place for direct science communication.
- All the information about his coaching programs, blood work, sleep programs, and other stuff can be found on his website Andy galpin.com.