Woodstock for the Adventurous and Responsible | Bret Weinstein & Heather Heying | EP 483
24 Sep 2024 (2 days ago)
Coming up
- The speaker, despite considering themselves secular, acknowledges a spiritual aspect to the ongoing struggle.
- The speaker observes the opposition employing demonic tropes for unclear reasons.
- The speaker believes the situation's stakes extend beyond the well-being of modern people, impacting humanity's ability to persist.
Intro
- A celebration, "Rescue the Republic", will occur in Washington D.C. on September 29th.
- The celebration will include musicians, comedians, and speakers, including Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and Tulsi Gabbard.
- The discussion also covered the connection between evolutionary biology and theology, and how they relate to the current political climate.
Bret and Heather at Peterson Academy
- The Peterson Academy launched on September 9th and has 31,000 students.
- The social media aspect of Peterson Academy is being curated to produce a positive social media network.
- Peterson Academy has a substantial entry fee to screen out bots, trolls, and manipulators.
The social media approach to learning: iterative feedback
- Individuals who are genuinely interested in learning within a specific online ecosystem require iterative feedback that provides rewards.
- Anonymous users in virtual spaces face challenges receiving iterative feedback due to the inability to track their reputation, hindering their ability to learn and engage in long-term endeavors.
- Social media algorithms, optimizing for short-term attention spans (15-30 seconds), tend to reward manipulative tactics that do not promote positive long-term development.
Combating the evolution of corruption
- It is important to create systems that are difficult to corrupt by making the cost of attempted corruption very high.
- AI may force a prioritization of things that cannot be easily faked, such as live events and certain types of music and comedy.
- Depression is a complex issue that can be caused by both physiological factors and challenging life circumstances.
The benefits of recorded lectures, future goals for in-person conventions
- Recorded lectures lack the dynamism of in-person lectures, but they can be carefully curated for quality and reach a larger audience.
- Future goals include creating a social landscape for students, such as watch parties and a 3-day convention with professors to foster social interaction and mentorship.
- The low cost of the online education model will allow for special in-person events to supplement the online experience and address the social aspect of education.
Cost of entry, managing bad actors, and the hierarchy of curation
- Free social media networks may be inherently flawed due to a lack of barriers to entry, potentially allowing for manipulation by actors with significant resources.
- Implementing a system that discourages inauthentic behavior, such as plagiarism or AI-generated content, could improve the quality of discourse.
- Establishing clear and simple rules, transparent moderation processes, and a system for appealing decisions can help create a fair and high-quality online community.
Why Hillsdale College has a 1% dropout rate in the first year
- Hillsdale College has a 1% dropout rate in the first year.
- Hillsdale College has an honor code and a code of behavior that students agree to abide by.
- Faculty in programs at Evergreen State College wrote covenants for their programs that outlined expectations for student and faculty behavior.
The difference between censorship and refereeing, leveraging evolution to continuously self-improve
- A valid set of rules is one that people voluntarily abide by.
- It is impossible to write a set of rules and anticipate how they will be manipulated, especially with actors who evolve in response.
- One solution is to deploy two similar sets of rules with an unknown difference and monitor which one functions better.
Elon Musk: adapting solutions faster than those who seek to game the system
- Elon Musk's solution for dealing with bad actors on Twitter involves a system similar to distributed cognition and market-based pricing.
- Musk's approach, while initially effective, faces challenges as it proves to be too static and susceptible to gaming.
- Traditional religious structures address the issue of discerning truth through a two-pronged approach: considering popular opinion while also referencing established traditions and lineage.
The orthodoxy of the past and predicting the future
- Orthodoxy, derived from the past, holds value due to its endurance and ability to withstand the test of time.
- It is crucial to avoid dismissing rare perspectives solely based on their scarcity, as groundbreaking ideas often emerge as unconventional viewpoints.
- A system of evaluation should consider three aspects: its present performance, its connection to past understanding, and its accuracy in predicting future outcomes.
Rescue the Republic - “We’re hoping this will be an event the way Woodstock was a music festival”
- The event, "Rescue the Republic," aims to be a pivotal moment signifying a shift in societal behavior and interaction, similar to the impact of Woodstock.
- The event will feature a diverse lineup of speakers, musicians, and comedians, including Bobby Kennedy, Tulsi Gabbard, Laura Logan, Russell Brand, Matt Taibi, Jimmy Dore, Rob Schneider, Skillet, Five Times August, and Tennessee Jet.
- A comprehensive list of participants and further information can be found at jointhe resistencia.org and on Twitter at rescu Republic.
The propositional must be surrounded by the imagistic, the opportunity for discovery
- The integration of artistic and musical elements is crucial because the propositional, or the realm of logic and reason, needs to be complemented by the imagistic and aesthetic, which is akin to the realm of dreams and imagination.
- A holistic experience encompasses three domains: the propositional landscape (well-modeled by language models), the imagistic and dreamlike landscape of imagination, and the embodied procedural realm.
- While the propositional is easier to define and capture, incorporating the imagistic, aesthetic, and procedural elements creates a richer, more engaging, and ultimately more profound and impactful experience.
Propositional intelligence — and what actually makes you wise
- Intellectuals may excel in propositional knowledge but that doesn't necessarily equate to wisdom.
- Wisdom might involve the alignment of propositional, imagistic, and procedural knowledge, suggesting an embodied and imaginative quality.
- There is no correlation between cognitive ability and conscientiousness, suggesting intelligence is independent of personality traits.
The edge traversed by comedians, the advent of the laugh track
- Comedians work in a space between what people are conscious and barely conscious of, using humor to reveal shared but unacknowledged awareness.
- Laughter, often involuntary, can be induced, as seen with laugh tracks, which can influence beliefs even if the humor isn't genuine.
- Comedy can operate on both individual and population levels, with shared laughter creating a sense of unity and shared understanding, even regarding taboo subjects.
The radical distortion of music, “music used to be a living entity”
- Technology has radically distorted music, beginning with the player piano.
- Music used to be a living entity, different every time it was played, and capable of adapting to the changing mood of the people participating in it.
- Modern people, surrounded by music all the time, miss the powerful and rare experience of a room unified by music and emotion.
Putting forth the pillars of our civilization, the exhausted middle
- The event will focus on articulating eight key principles that are believed to be widely agreed upon by patriotic Americans but are currently under threat.
- These principles are being jeopardized by what are referred to as "industrial complexes."
- The event aims to highlight the existence of a significant "exhausted middle" comprised of individuals who largely agree on important issues but are overshadowed by polarized factions.
A secular thinker on the spiritual battle we are all engaged in
- There is a spiritual dimension to the current societal situation, and the language of religion is increasingly necessary to describe the severity of the situation.
- Religious language encapsulates the severity of the situation and provides tools for dealing with it, even if those tools are not commonly used.
- While a secular explanation exists for the spiritual dimension of the current situation, it is not necessary to articulate it at this time, as the focus should be on practical solutions.
The necessity of narrative, translating for the secular
- People who identify as secular may be more receptive to arguments that do not rely on religious or spiritual language.
- Religious language should be reserved for situations and concepts that cannot be adequately explained using secular or reductionist terms.
- Humans perceive and understand the world through narratives, and while these narratives can be influenced by power dynamics, they are not inherently or inevitably about power.
The title toward the demonic, using AI to map the pattern of the Logos
- Large language models can map the relationships between ideas, similar to how they identify statistical regularities between words, phrases, and larger text structures.
- Psychoanalysts, particularly Carl Jung, recognized a connection between complexes of ideas and associated images and dramas.
- Embracing a specific set of ideas can lead to an influx of associated imagery and narratives within one's imagination, akin to the concept of possession.
Prayer, revelation, and the spirit of the question
- Large language models (LLMs) make implicit knowledge explicit based on the specific questions asked, suggesting that the "spirit" of the question influences the answer.
- This concept extends to human consciousness, where the quality of insights and revelations might be influenced by the underlying intention and spirit of the inquiry.
- This implies that even without the existence of a deity, approaching inquiry with a pure pursuit of truth might yield genuine and valuable insights, similar to how a scientist strives for objectivity in hypothesis generation.
Brick-in-the-wall science, hypothesis generation
- A diverse range of scientists asking questions will not change the answers science arrives at, but it will change the questions asked.
- Hypothesis generation is the most important part of the scientific endeavor, but it is often overlooked.
- The ability to identify patterns at a fundamental level is what separates great scientific minds from those who simply build upon existing knowledge.
The relation between openness and divergent associations, hierarchies of mutational repair
- Openness does not correlate with scientific productivity, while conscientiousness does.
- Individuals with high openness tend to generate more divergent and statistically improbable ideas, which can be both revolutionary and incorrect.
- The genome possesses a hierarchical system of mutational repair, where genes crucial for survival are repaired with higher accuracy than less critical ones.
A new convergence on a shared perspective, the need of God to answer prayers
- It is suggested that a convergence of perspectives is occurring among thinkers, indicating a potential discovery of something real regardless of one's starting point.
- The idea that God does not need to exist to answer prayers is presented, along with an evolutionary explanation for how prayer could work.
- Praying about a problem before bed could prime the mind to dream about it, potentially leading to waking up with insights, which is a known phenomenon.
Richard Dawkins, winning with your own audience rather than making substantive progress
- Richard Dawkins is very close to seeing something important that would make his work more important, but he is avoiding a necessary conversation.
- Religions that have stood the test of time are very metaphorical, while scientific fields like chemistry and physics are more literal because of our greater understanding of them.
- Dreams are a product of adaptive evolution that allow us to explore possibilities by violating rules; many of these explorations are not fruitful, but some lead to transcendent connections.
What the ancients knew about the delusion of being, metaphorical models in science
- Even if God is not real in a traditional sense, the revelations that emerge from seeking a higher power are deeply real because they reflect the relationship between the individual, the social community, and the natural world.
- Humans suffer from a delusion about the significance of self, as evolution prioritizes the continuation of lineage over the individual.
- Scientific models, particularly in biology, are largely metaphorical because our understanding is constantly evolving and being refined with new discoveries.
Dawkins’ one error in “The Selfish Gene”
- Richard Dawkins's concept of memes, as presented in "The Selfish Gene," is flawed because he posits them as a new evolutionary realm rather than a solution that evolved within the realm of genes.
- Memes are not a lateral solution but a downstream one, operating within the framework of genes while enabling faster adaptation and incorporating virtual death, allowing for more experimentation and learning.
- The significance of memes lies in their ability to explain the exceptional capabilities of human beings, surpassing even Dawkins's own initial examples.